Industry:Manufacturer of components for transportation
Department:Production engineering division

When a Sample Fails Quality Testing

What is the secret that enables Nissin Manufacturing to pass clients’ stringent quality tests when others fail?

Background

The manufacturer featured in this case study produces precision-machined components for transportation which must meet some of the most demanding precision. As the manufacturer’s existing bore finishing machine was ageing, it was planning to progressively replace its equipment, but the new equipment would have to pass its client’s stringent quality tests.

Problem

Seemingly-Straightforward Machine Replacement Creates Unexpected Challenges

The manufacturer’s production engineering division put together a dedicated team to select the new machine, and the team began considering a few options. The replacement machine needed to have certain features and meet certain conditions.

  • The replacement machine needed to be a bore finishing machine that satisfied the clients’ stringent bore accuracy requirements.

  • Because workpieces had complex shapes, making alignment a time-consuming process, the machine needed to be able to position the components with one-touch.

  • To ensure consistent precision, the machine had to be able to automate, and improve on, the subtle adjustments that skilled operators had been performing manually.

The machine needed to both pass client quality tests and satisfy the demands of those on the factory. The team narrowed down the options (for which test would be commissioned) to honing machines produced by three different suppliers.

The team leader recalls:
“Our top priority was passing the client’s quality tests. To this end, we provided drawings to the machine suppliers and had them run trials. Our plan was to install a bore finishing machine that met our functional and other requirements, made by a supplier that passed the quality tests.”

Immediately, the team took the test samples to the client for quality testing. However, counter to their expectations, all three samples were rejected. The team leader was stunned.

Summary of the problem

  • The team needed to select a supplier that made a bore finishing machine capable of passing the client's quality test that could ascertain, and deliver, the level of accuracy required for the tests.

  • Because the workpieces came in complex shapes, making alignment time-consuming, the machine needed to be able to position the components with one-touch.

  • The machine needed to be able to automatically perform the diameter measurement and fine adjustment necessary to ensure consistent diameter dimensions. This process was previously performed by skilled operators.

1 2